Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York January 11, 1907 (Empire Trust Co. v. Magee)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-01-1907
Ingraham, J.:
The action was upon a promissory note. The 2d clause of the complaint alleges that “ on or about tbe 18th day of September, 1905, defendant made his certain promissory note in writing, dated on that day, whereby for value received, he promised to pay to the order of himself, one month after said date, the sum of seven hundred dollars at Empire Trust Company, New York City, with interest at six per cent per annum; and said defendant on or about said date, duly indorsed the said note and for value delivered the same to the plaintiff, who is now the owner and holder thereof.”
The answer denies that “ the allegations contained in paragraph ‘ Second ’ of said complaint which allege that defendant made his certain promissory note for value received and denies that for value he delivered the same to plaintiff.”
The other allegation of the complaint being admitted, it follows that the defendant does not deny that he made the promissory note *36and delivered the same to the plaintiff, the denial only being that he made the ' nóte for value and for value delivered '.the same to the plaintiff.
The first defense alleged is that at the' commencement of this action there was pending an action in the Supreme' Court between parties who, though nominally different, are in reality the" same as in this action, and for the same cause as that set forth in the complaint herein, namely, to recover the sum of $700-, alleged to have .been advanced to defendant by Le Roy W. Baldwin, which sum is the alleged consideration for the note set forth in the complaint herein; that in reference to said alleged claim of $700 for which said note was given, the plaintiff herein represents and is the agent of said Le Roy W. Baldwin ; that plaintiff herein had notice and knowledge of all the facts in reference thereto, and if it advanced any money on said note, it did so at the request and for the account of said Le Roy AY. Baldwin, its president. The second defense alleged .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit