New York Supreme Court July 15, 1907 (Watts v. Equitable Life Assurance Society)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-1907

Tompkins, J.

The plaintiff is the holder of a semi-ton-tine insurance policy by which policy the defendant agreed, in consideration of a certain yearly premium, to pay to the plaintiff, at the expiration of twenty years, a certain sum of money, provided the policy had not sooner lapsed, or had been terminated by death; and also agreed at the expiration of that period that it would apportion equitably, among such of its policies of the same class as that held by plaintiff as should complete their tontine dividend periods, all surplus of profits derived from such of its policies on the semi-tontine plan a,s should not be in force at the date of the completion of their respective tontine periods.

The complaint sets forth the substance of the insurance policy and alleges that the plaintiff has complied with all its terms and conditions; and then alleges, upon information and belief, that the defendant wrongfully and unlawfully neglected to determine the just and equitable proportion of the assets which were, under the terms of the said policy, to be allotted to him, and arbitrarily and unjustly fixed plaintiff’s share at a sum less than that to which he is equitably entitled; and that defendant, during the continuance of said policy, wrongfully appropriated the surplus of profits derived from policies on the same plan as that of plaintiff’s and diverted them to wrongful and illegal purposes, and has improperly, and with intent to deprive plaintiff of the profit to which he is entitled, withheld and passed into the accumulated reserve, and, in bad faith, withheld and refused to distribute, amounts greatly in excess of those sufficient to secure the rafety of its policy-holders; and asks that the defendant be ordered to account to the plaintiff for its transactions affecting the said policy, and that it be directed to pay to plaintiff the sum found to be due thereupon.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.