Supreme Court of Pennsylvania October 7, 1907, No. 1; Appeal, No. 5 (Reynolds Street Sewer)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-10-1907

Opinion by

Henderson, J.,

Under an ordinance approved October 2,1900, the city of Pittsburg constructed a sewer on Reynolds street with lateral branches on intersecting streets. After the completion of the work, viewers were appointed on the petition of the cityr to ascertain the cost, damages and expenses and assess the benefits growing out of the improvement. Exceptions were filed by the appellant which were overruled by the court — hence, this appeal. Two objections are made to the action of the viewers : (1) that the exceptor was charged with benefits for the purpose of paying land damages to other property owners ; and (2) the viewers should have assessed benefits and damages for the sewer oh each street as a separate improvement. The exceptions were dismissed without prejudice to the right of the ex-ceptor to raise the same question on appeal. A third exception was filed alleging that the assessment was excessive, but its dismissal is not assigned for error and we may assume that it is not maintained by the facts. No testimony was taken and the questions involved must be determined by the record presented. We do not find anything which furnishes a sufficient basis to sustain the first exception. The whole cost of the sewer as shown by the report of the viewers was $96,517.58. There was the additional cost of $16,851 for damages, apart from special benefits, making the entire cost of the improvement *212$113,868.58. Of this sum more than $48,000 was assessed against the city of Pittsburg. In the face of this showing it cannot be successfully alleged that the appellant was charged with any part of the land damages allowed other property owners. The city was clearly made liable not only for these damages, but for a large part of the cost of the construction of the sewer. As there can be no assessment of benefits in sewer cases to pay land damages (Mill Creek Sewer, 196 Pa. 183; Barnett’s Case, 28 Pa. Superior Ct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.