Missouri Court of Appeals December 2, 1907 (State v. Weyland)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-12-1907
ELLISON, J.
The defendant was convicted of being a licensed dramshop keeper and selling intoxicating liquor on Sunday. He has brought the case here by appeal.
The prosecuting attorney of Jasper county filed an information against the defendant verified by his oath. It contained three counts. The first charged that defendant was a licensed dramshop keeper on Sunday, the 18th day of March, 1906, and that on that day he sold intoxicating liquor at such dramshop. The second charged a different offense in that he sold the liquor on that day and that he was not a licensed dramshop keeper. The third charged that he sold liquor on that day, but does not allege anything as to his having a license or of his being a dramshop keeper. At the foot of the information following his signature is the prosecuting attorney’s affidavit, “that the facts stated in the foregoing information are true according to his best information and belief.” The defendant demurred to the information and the demurrer was overruled. At the opening of the trial the State elected “to stand on the first count,” but no new verification was made.
It will be observed that the information, as a whole, presents the strange anomaly of charging defendant with being a licensed dramshop keeper at a certain time and place and with not being a licensed dramshop keeper at the same time and place. The first and second count are point-blank contradictions, each of the other. If we assume that in ordinary pleading different counts may state the same transaction, or act, in different ways, so as to cover the case made by the evidence, yet where, as here, a criminal pleading is required to be sworn to, in order to constitute a valid charge, it cannot be that it is allowable for it to contain directly contradictory statements of facts vital to the charge. Where an affidavit is required to a pleading the latter must be such a paper as, upon its face, may be sworn to as *726true.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit