Supreme Court of Iowa October 23, 1907 (Hubbell v. Hubbell)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-10-1907

Ladd, J.

The vital inquiry in this case is whether the trust deed confers on the trustees power to execute a ground lease for building purposes extending into the future a period of ninety-nine years.. It specifies the powers and duties they are to exercise, and in express terms excludes all others. They are not “ to sell or dispose of ” the property described in Schedule A, which includes that in controversy, save for party walls, streets, and other public purposes, but “ shall have power to lease said property, and to demand, collect, sue, and receipt for the rents, issues, and profits arising, and which may be had therefrom,” and “ to maintain, improve, and insure ” the same. The duration of leases to be executed is not indicated, save in the clause requiring the signature of a majority of the trustees to all instruments in writing, excepting “ leases for terms not exceeding five (5) years, checks, drafts, receipts and vouchers” which may be signed by any person designated by the trustees.. The extent of the property conveyed, and the conditions of the trust, preclude all questions of necessity in the matter of the preservation of the estate, and neither this nor the de*643mands to meet any fixed charges is urged in justification of this long term for which the lease is drawn.

1. Estates of descendants: trust property: leases. The rent stipulated is not so inadequate that a court of equity should interfere. While the evidence shows that ground rentals in Des Moines for like periods average considerably higher than that agreed upon, and these are customarily computed at more fre- . . - _ quent estimates of value, it cannot be said that the trustees in stipulating for 4 per cent, net of the value of the ground per annum, subject to an appraisal every twenty-five years, as compensation for its use, have not acted discreetly and for the best interests of the estate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.