Court of Appeals of Kentucky December 5, 1907 (Hart v. Bank of Russellville)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1907

Opinion op the Court by

Judge Settle-

Reversing.

Appellee, Bank of Russellville, sued the appellant, Moss E. Hart, and her husband, S. B. Hart, in the court below upon two notes; one of $150, bearing date November 29, 1905, due 120 days after date, and the other $250, bearing date December 26, 1905, and due 90 days thereafter. It is admitted that these two notes were renewals of what was left of a matured note of $500 which had previously been executed to the bank by the same parties, and upon which S. B. Hart had paid $100. The appellant, Moss E. Hart, by separate answer, which was later amended, interposed, in substance, the defense that she signed the two notes in question and the original note of $500 as the surety of S. B. Hart, who was then and is now her husband; that they were executed for money borrowed by him of appellee, no part of which was received by her; and that by reason of her coverture and suretyship no liability was incurred by her in placing her signature to the notes. The affirmative matter of the answer as amended was controverted by reply, thereby completing the issues as to the question of appellant’s liability upon the notes. There was, however, yet another matter involved in the litigation which seems to have been withdrawn by the parties, or settled. By agreement of parties, a jury was waived, and upon submission of the law and facts to the court judgment was rendered against the appellant, Moss E. Hart, in appellee’s favor, for the amounts respectively of the notes in suit. Appellant applied for and was refused a new trial. Hence this appeal.

*426"Was the appellant, Moss E. Hart, upon the facts presented by the record', principal in the two notes sued on, or only the surety thereon of her husband, S. B. Hart? It is insisted for appellee that, because appellant’s name appeared first on the notes, it had the right to presume she was the principal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.