Michigan Supreme Court December 10, 1907, Docket No. 138 (Schulte v. Pfaudler Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-12-1907
Moore, J.
The plaintiff entered into the employ of defendant when he was past 22 years of age. He worked several weeks in the latter part of 1902. He was then sick for a time. He returned to work about the first of *428January, 1903, and worked until April 30th, when he got his arm in the cogs of a punching machine upon which he was at work, receiving injuries which resulted in the loss of his arm. This suit was brought to recover damages for said injuries. The trial judge directed a verdict in favor of defendant. The case is brought here by writ of error.
The declaration claims in substance :
(1) That leaving the cogwheels uncovered was a violation of section 5349, 2 Comp. Laws.
(2) That the place where the punch machine was located was not sufficiently lighted.
(3) That there was not sufficient space about the machine for plaintiff’s work.
(4) That the belt was an old one, which had been frequently mended; and
(5) That plaintiff was not warned as to the danger which he would incur in cleaning the machine.
Counsel insist that where the defendant neglects the statutory duty of safeguarding machines, it cannot be held that the plaintiff assumed the risks attendant upon the absence of safeguards, because the assumption of risks is the result of .the contract of employment, and the master cannot legally contract to violate a statute, and is not in position to assert, as against the servant, the doctrine of assumed risk, even in case where the omission of the statutory duty is known to the servant. Citing Sipes v. Starch Co., 137 Mich. 258.
Counsel for defendant insist upon several defenses, some of which it will not be necessary to consider.
The testimony of plaintiff and a picture of a machine in all its essential parts, the same as the one upon which the injury occurred, shows the machine to be of simple construction. The cogs were plainly visible. Plaintiff knew it would be disastrous for him to come in contact with them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit