Supreme Court of Minnesota March 1, 1907, Nos. 15,026—(164) (Freddie Pearl Masteller v. Great Northern Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-03-1907
lewis, J.
Respondent was a section hand working with a crew of eleven men on the Osakis division of appellant’s railway. On the day of the accident they had been at work on the main track, some ten miles east of Osakis, and at the close of the day, about six o’clock, on the third day of November, 1904, were returning to Osakis upon a hand car, running six or seven miles an hour, and collided with another hand car coming from the opposite direction, carrying a bridge crew, also in appellant’s employ. Respondent was thrown off, and received injuries upon which this action was founded. The negligence charged in the complaint was that the bridge crew was negligent in failing to keep a watchful lookout, in not properly controlling the car to avoid *237collisions, and, further, that the section foreman, in charge of the crew of which respondent was a member, was negligent in failing to keep a lookout, and in not discovering the car upon which the bridge crew were approaching, and in failing to control or stop the car, and to take proper means to avoid the accident. The cause went to trial. The jury returned a verdict of $12,500. Appellant made a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, and, in case that should be denied, for a new trial upon several grounds, including excessive damages, appearing to have been given under the influence of passion or prejudice. The trial court denied the motion for judgment, but granted the motion for a new trial unless appellant should consent to have the verdict reduced to $9,000.
The motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict was based upon the ground that it conclusively appeared from the evidence that the collision was the result of the unauthorized acts of the bridge -crew in trespassing upon the main track with a hand car, and that appellant was in no manner responsible therefor, and that no negligence was shown on the part of the foreman of the section crew.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit