Tennessee Supreme Court September 15, 1907 (State v. Smith)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1907
Mr. Justice Neil
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The indictment in this case charged that the plaintiff in error “on the-day of April, 1906, and on divers other days prior to that date, and up to the finding of this indictment, in the State and county aforesaid, did unlawfully, knowingly, willfully, and feloniously cut and remove from said tract of land” (previously described in the indictment) “timber growing upon said *524land, for the purpose of marketing the same, without the consent of said John G. Myers and William 0. Johnson, the owners in fee of said tract of land, contrary to the said form of the statute in such case made and provided, and against the peace and dignity of the State.”
This indictment was based on chapter 106, p. 257, of the Acts of 1897. That act provides that it shall be a felony for any one to “knowingly, willfully, and maliciously cut or to remove, for the purpose of marketing the same, timber from the lands of another, without the consent of the owner of the timber so cut or removed.”
By chapter 381, p. 889, of the Acts of 1899, an effort was made to amend the foregoing statute by striking out the words “and maliciously;” but this latter act is vdd, because it violates article 2, section 17, of the constitution, since it does not recite in its caption or otherwise the title or substance of the law sought to be amended. Memphis Street Ry. Co. v. State, 110 Tenn., 598, 75 S. W., 730.
In the court below the indictment in the present case was quashed because it omitted the word “maliciously,” and substituted therefor the word “feloniously.” The question to be determined is whether the substituted word supplied the place of the word omitted.
It is always best to pursue the words of the statute; but where a word not in the statute is substituted for one that is, and the word thus substituted is equivalent to the word used in the statute, or is of more extensive *525signification than it, and includes it, tlie indictment will be sufficient.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit