Tennessee Supreme Court September 15, 1907 (Hurd v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1907
Me. Justice McAlister
delivered the opinion of the Oourt.
The prisoner was convicted in the criminal court of Hamilton county for the crime of murder in the first degree, with the judgment of death, for the unlawful killing of one T. O. Musgrove. The deceased was a policeman of the city of Chattanooga, hut at the time of his death was dressed in citizen’s clothes, and it does not distinctly appear that the prisoner knew at that time the deceased was a police officer. The theory of the state is that Musgrove at the time of his death was attempting to arrest defendant, Hurd, for the offense of unlawfully carrying a pistol.
The shooting, which resulted in the death of Musgrove a few hours later, occurred about 9 or 9:30 o’clock p. m., on White street, in South Chattanooga, near the saloon of one E. L. Shepherd. This saloon was' situated on the corner of Whiteside and White streets, fronting on the east side of Whiteside street and running back along the north side of WTliite street. There are large glass doors in the front of the saloon, and at the rear end. of the building there was a door leading from the back room of the saloon out into White street. The saloon was divided by a partition into two rooms, and the front room was known as the white bar, and the rear room as the colored bar; but there seems to have been an indiscriminate mixing of the whites and blacks at each of these bars. Witnesses testified that this saloon was the usual loafing place of Musgrove, the deceased, when *586he was off duty. At the time of the tragedy, deceased was off duty, and had been around the saloon for some hours, sitting in the back room with some white men and some negroes; and it is stated by the barkeeper, a State’s witness, that Musgrove was endeavoring to sober up, as he was'expecting to go on duty the same night. Among other persons in the back room with deceased were J. D. Drennan, who, the barkeeper says, had been drinking, but was also sobering up.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit