Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit June 10, 1907, No. 15 (The Pacific)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-06-1907

LANNING, District Judge.

This is a collision case. Three vessels are concerned in it — the dredge Pacific, the tug S. A. McCauley, and the steamship Maiing. The collision resulted in damage to the *944dredge amounting, with interest and costs, to the sum 'of $19,754.70. By the final decree of the District Court all three of the vessels were adjudged to have been in fault, and one-third of the damages was apportioned to each of them. The steamship abides by the decree, and has paid the one-third assessed against it. The tug and the dredge (with her insurers) have appealed, and by the' errors assigned have presented questions concerning the negligence and contributory negligence of the several vessels.

The collision occurred in the Delaware river, below Philadelphia, on the night of November 16, 1897. The night was dark, but clear. The dredge was anchored in the easterly side of the river, bow down. The tug was tied to the westerly side of the dredge, bow up, her stern projecting some feet below the dredge’s bow, and the dredge’s stern projecting some feet above the tug’s bow. The steamship, in passing down the river, struck the dredge and did the damage complained of. The dredge for some months had been engaged under employment of the United States government in dredging out the navigable channel of the river 90 feet on the westerly side and 175 feet on the easterly side of the line of the Edgemoor range lights. For some days previous to the collision the dredge had been working on the easterly side of this line. About 5 o’clock in the afternoon, just preceding the collision, she was. removed to a point about 350 feet easterly of the line of the range lights, and there anchored for the night. Her anchor lines, extending to the west, toward and across the dredged channel, were weighted and submerged. Those extending to the east, away from the dredged channel, were not submerged. The dredge’s lights indicated that she was at anchor..

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.