U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern New York June 11, 1907 (American Graphophone Co. v. International Record Co.)

EACOMBE, Circuit Judge.

This patent was sustained and construed by the Court of Appeals upon voluminous records and after a long hearing on exhaustive briefs. Am. Graph. Co. v. Universal Talking M. M. Co. and Same v. American Record Co. (C. C. A. Second Circuit, Jan. 14, 1907), 151 Fed. 595. This creates a presumption in favor of the patent, which defendant must rebut by satisfactory proof.