District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania October 15, 1907, No. 36 of 1905 (The Ranza)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1907
HOIyLAND, District judge.
On September 25, 1905, Patrick Mul-herin filed his libel against the steamship Ranza to recover damages for personal injuries sustained on the afternoon of August 31, 1905, while working as a stevedore upon the vessel. On November 28, 1905, he died, and subsequently, on January 12, 1906, his widow and adminis-tratrix, upon petition filed, was substituted as party libelant. The deceased, a stevedore in the employ of Grace Bros., was one of the gang of men assigned to discharge a cargo of iron ore as soon as the Ranza was berthed at Girard Point on the Delaware river. He was directed, with other men, to open hatch No. 3 on the main deck in order to unload the ore then stored in the between decks. Mulherin and three other men were assigned to do this work. They removed the covers from the main deck hatch, but it was necessary that the between deck’s hatch of hatch No. 3 should be covered to enable them to remove the part of the cargo stored between decks. They proceeded to place covers upon the hatch, and had covered the aft opening of the hatch when the accident occurred. Hatch No. 3, at which the accident happened, is divided into three sections by two iron athwart ship 0beams built with the ship, in which were places for nine wooden fore and afters, three to each section. The hatch covers were of wood, and ran athwart ship the full width of the hatch, 12 feet in length.
*374There is a conflict of evidence as to whether or not the two after
covers in the after section of the hatch were in place when the men descended to the between decks, but the weight of the evidence is to the effect that these covers were'not in place and that they were put on by Mulherin and the men themselves. They were unable to find fore and afters of the proper length, and went to the upper deck and secured a number which would not fit, and they placed them “catacor-nered under the hatch covers.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit