U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Northern California October 4, 1907, No. 13,097 (Nome Beach Lighterage & Transp. Co. v. Standard Marine Ins.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-10-1907

DE HAVEN, District Judge.

There was technical error in sustaining the plaintiff’s objection to defendant’s offer to prove what Capt John L. Panno testified to upon the former trial of this action; Capt. Panno having died since the giving of that testimony. Ruch v. Rock Island, 97 U. S. 693, 24 L. Ed. 1101; Mattox v. United States, 166 U. S. 237, 15 Sup. Ct. 337, 39 L. Ed. 409; United States v. Macomb, 5 McLean, 286, Fed. Cas. No. 15,702; Greenleaf on Evidence, § 163. Section 861 of the Revised Statutes [U. S. Comp. St. 1901, p. 661], which provides: “The mode of proof in the trial of actions at common law shall be by oral testimony and examination of witnesses in open court, except as hereinafter provided” — and the succeeding sections, providing for the taking of depositions, do not bear upon the question of the right to prove the testimony of a deceased witness; nor do Ex parte Fisk, 113 U. S. 713, 5 Sup. Ct. 724, 28 L. Ed. 1117, Diamond Coal & Coke Co. v. Allen, 137 Fed. 705, 71 C. C. A. 107, Mulcahey v. Lake Erie & W. R. Co. (C. C.) 69 Fed, 172, which are relied upon by the plaintiff, apply. The question of the admissibility of evidence to prove the testimony given by a deceased witness was not presented in any of those cases.

I am, however, satisfied that the error in sustaining the objection of this offered evidence was harmless, as the deposition of Capt. Panno taken at the instance of the defendant was received in evidence, and there was no substantial difference between it and the oral testimony given by him upon the former trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.