U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Massachusetts November 9, 1907, No. 179 (Weiss v. Haight & Freese Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-11-1907
1,0WELL, Circuit Judge.
The court has found, and now finds, that the respondent, the Haight & Freese Company, was a bucket shop, holding itself out as a broker for the purchase of securities; that for the most part it appropriated the money received from its customers without any purchase of securities for their' account. It usually represented to its customers that the money so received had been lost in making good the margins upon the purchases which the customers had directed. For obvious reasons, however, the company represented to some of its customers that their speculations had resulted in profit. Had all customers lost all their money, the company after a time would have ceased to attract.
A customer defrauded in the manner first described has been allowed to prove in this proceeding for the sums which he paid to the company, without regard either to the agreement under which the payments were made or to the state of his accounts as shown by the company’s books. In effect, he is thus permitted to rescind his contract because of the company’s fraud, and to enforce a claim for money had and received by the company to his use. Thus far there is no dispute.
But those customers, comparatively few in number, who appear upon the company’s books to have succeeded in their speculations, and so to .be entitled to. more money than they paid into the company, naturally wish to prove for the larger sum, upon a trade basis, so-called, rather .than upon the cash basis just referred to. Where there was collusion between the customer and the company, this cannot be permitted.' But, in cases where the master has found no evidence of the customer’s knowledge of the company’s fraudulent practices, no one has appeared to oppose the customer’s claim to payment upon a trade basis. After careful consideration, the receiver is inclined to think that the trade basis is admissible as a measure of proof alternative at the option of the creditor.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit