District Court, D. Maine November 30, 1907, No. 69 (The James T. Furber)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-11-1907
HALE, District Judge.
The claim of Thomas E. Bolton in this-case is for services rendered to the James T. Furber, a domestic vessel in her home port, after she had gone out of commission for the season and was hauled up at Long Wharf. The work consisted of pumping the steamer’ out, looking after the lines, and general oversight of the vessel. All these services were performed at the request of Baker, the owner.
In The Cimbria, 156 Fed. 378, the Massachusetts District Court sustained the claim of a seaman for piloting the steamer to Lockwood' Wharf, attending to making her fast there, and looking out for her safety while there. Judge Dodge said:
“I think 1 am justified in regarding these services, preceding as they did the-final laying up of the boat, as maritime, and in holding that his claim for them is good as against the vessel.”
In that case the Cimbria was a foreign vessel,» and the services-preceded the hauling up of the boat. In the claim at bar the services-*125were rendered to a domestic vessel, and after the laying up of the vessel at the wharf. It will be seen that the domestic lien statute of the state of Maine (Rev. St. c. 93, § 7) does not attempt to provide a lien for any such claim. The claim cannot, then, be allowed, unless it was distinctly for the services of a seaman. In The Hattie Thomas (D. C.) 59 Fed. 297, Judge Townsend said:
“This exception raises a difficult question, and one concerning which there has been much conflict of authority.”
He makes the test, however, to be as to whether the services are such as would be rendered by a mariner; and, if they are of this character, he holds them to be of equal rank with those of other seamen, and to constitute a lien upon the vessel. See, also, The Sirius (D. C.) 65 Fed. 226; The C. Vanderbilt (D. C.) 86 Fed. 785; The Harriet, Fed. Cas. No. 6,097.
Judge Townsend recognizes the rule in this circuit laid down in The Island City, 1 Rowell, 378, Fed. Cas. No.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit