Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit November 7, 1907, No. 28 (Lobel v. Cossey)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-11-1907

COXE, Circuit Judge.

In an interference proceeding between these parties the Commissioner of Patents, by virtue of the authority vested in him by law, fixed the time in which the parties were required to take testimony as follows: Eobel was to close his testimony May 22, 1906; Cossey’s rebuttal was to close June 6, and the final hearing was to be July 6, 1906. Eobel was produced as a witness in his own behalf on May 2ist, his direct examination was concluded and he was handed over for - cross-examination to Cossey’s counsel and was examined by him until the midday recess on the 22d of May, which was Tuesday. On reconvening in the afternoon counsel for Eobel asked for a few days’ adjournment, which was granted, and the hearing was set for Friday of the same week. On that day, at the earnest solicitation of Eobel’s general attorney, his counsel having withdrawn from the case, the proceedings were again adjourned until Monday, the 28th of May, and again until May 31st. New counsel having been secured, a further adjournment was had until June 4th, when counsel announced that no further testimony would be taken on behalf of Eobel who would stand on his record date. Counsel also stated that he would not produce Eobel before the examiner or consent to his being cross-examined further.

Thereafter, Lobel, having failed to appear before the clerk of the Circuit Court to continue his cross-examination, after having been" duly summoned to do so, the order punishing him for contempt, which is now under review, was made by the Circuit Court. It will thus be seen that Eobel was not produced as a witness until the last day, but one, for taking his testimony, but even so, a full day remained for cross-examination.

Making every allowance for the proverbial prolixity of examinations in patent cases, there was, it would seem, ample time to have concluded the testimony on the 22d had not Lobel, through his counsel, requested an adjournment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.