Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit October 1, 1907, No. 1,372 (Schultz v. Scott)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-10-1907

GROSSCUP, Circuit Judge.

The petitioners are lumber dealers who, prior to the commencement of proceedings in bankruptcy, had shipped to the Planett Manufacturing Company, upon the order of that company, a car load of oak lumber. The respondent is the trustee appointed by the District Court in the bankruptcy proceedings. The purpose of the petition is to review, revise, and reverse an order of the District Court, affirming the recommendation of the referee, finding that the petitioners were not entitled to retain the lumber, and dispose of it as a part of the assets of the estate. The case turns upon .whether at the time the trustee took possession, title to the lumber had already passed from the petitioners to the bankrupt.

The amount of lumber in the car load ordered was eleven thousand six hundred,twenty-nine feet, and the price thirty two dollars per thousand. Upon the arrival of the car at La Porte, Indiana, where the Planett Manufacturing Company is located, the lumber was unloaded and inspected by the Planett Company, whereupon the following letter was sent to the petitioners: “We find this car to run considerably short in measurements, and besides, that the lumber is not up to grade. According to our careful tally, we find only nine thousand, four hundred sixty-seven feet of common oak, the balance 1,812 feet' is only a very poor grade of cull, which we could not accept for more than $17.00 a thousand. We herewith hand you a debit mem*917orandum showing the difference between amount billed us, and the actual contents of the car, amounting to $38.39. We are now holding this car subject to your inspection, so if you desire, you can run down here and convince yourself of the grade of this lumber.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.