Supreme Court of the United States April 8, 1907, 481 (Johnson v. Browne)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-04-1907

Mr. Justice Peckham,

after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court.

It does not appear that any movement has been made or notice given by this Government to try the respondent on the indictment for the crime for which he has been extradited, but his imprisonment in Sing Sing.Prison is upon a conviction of a crime for which the Canadian court had refused to extradite him, and is entirely different from the one for which he was extradited. In other words, he has been extradited for one offense and is now imprisoned for another, which the Canadian court held was not, within the treaty, ?n extraditable offense.

' Whether the crime came within the provision of the treaty was a matter for the decision of the Dominion authorities, and such decision was final by the express terms of the treaty itself. Article 2, Convention of July 12, 1889, 26 Stat. 1508;' United States Treaties in Force, April 28, 1904, 350, 351.

We can readily conceive .that if the Dominion authorities, after the Court of King’s Bench had decided that the crime of which respondent had been convicted' and for which extradition had been asked was not extraditable, and-the. request for extradition had, therefore, been refused, had been informed on the subsequent proceeding for extradition on the other indictment that it was not the intention of this Government to try respondent on that indictment, but that having securéd his extradition on that charge, it was the intention

*317

of this Government to imprison him on the judgment of conviction, they would have said that such imprisonment would not be according to the terms of the treaty, and they would have refused to direct his extradition for the purpose stated.

Although the surrender has been made, it is still our duty to determine the legality of the succeeding imprisonment, which depends upon the treaty between this Government and Great Britain, known as the Ashburton treaty of 1842, 8 Stat. 572-576, Art.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.