California Supreme Court December 31, 1908, L.A. No. 2172. (Payne v. Neuval)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-1908

MELVIN, J.

This is an appeal from a judgment for plaintiffs and from an order denying the motion of defendants for a new trial. The action was one to quiet title, and around a certain document set forth in the complaint cluster all of the problems presented by this appeal. The instrument in question was executed by the grantors of plaintiffs in favor of defendants’ decedent. It is in substantially the following language:—■

“In consideration of one dollar to me paid by P. Nivard Neuval, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, and the further sum of twenty cents per ton, I, the undersigned, grant to said P. Nivard Neuval all the bituminous rock, petro

*48

leum, asphaltum and other mineral which he may choose to mine, quarry and take from my land in San Luis Obispo County, State of California. (Here follows, a description of the property.) Together with the right of free ingress and egress and also the right to erect and maintain on said land stables, shed, house, sidetrack and other structures necessary to the business of mining and transferring such mineral to market. In case said land fails to produce such mineral in paying quantities or of good quality said F. Nivard Neuval may upon thirty days’ notice given to me in writing, abandon and relinquish to me all right hereby conferred and granted, and whereas I have a portion of my land cultivated and have planted vine and an orchard such portion now improved will be free from any mining and quarrying. P. N. Neuval agrees to take at least three hundred tons a year or to pay the royalty on that amount whether taken or not.”

This instrument was duly acknowledged and recorded on April 12, 1890. Immediately thereafter P. Nivard Neuval entered upon Bickmore’s land, quarried and took away twenty-seven tons of bituminous rock, after which he removed his machinery, both from that and from an adjoining tract of land, and never pursued any further mining or other operations in that vicinity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.