Court of Appeals of Maryland December 9, 1908 (Lord v. Smith)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1908

*44

Worthington, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The litigation in this case grows out of a dispute between the parties as to which is the proprietor of a certain brokerage business carried -on in Baltimore City for a number of years past under the trade name and style of Charles W. Lord & Co.

The appellant, who was the complainant below, claims that the business was established by him in 1895, and has ever since been conducted by him as the sole proprietor, with the appellee (the defendant below) as his trusted and confidential clerk. While, on the other hand, the appellee contends that the business was established in 1895 by him, and that it has ever since been cohducted by him as sole proprietor, with the appellant as his clerk.

According to the testimony of the parties themselves, neither of them was aware of the claims and pretensions of the other until the month of Hovember, 1907, when a controversy took place between them concerning the ownership of the business, and Mr. Lord, according to his testimony, claimed the whole; but according to Mr. Smith’s testimony, Mr. Lord said in the course of that controversy that he had as much interest in the business as Smith had; that half of it was his. At the same time Smith claimed that the whole business belonged to him.

Shortly after this conversation, that is to say, on December 24th, 1907, Mr. Lord filed the bill of complaint in this case in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City, setting forth his claims to the business as sole proprietor, alleging that he had established the business in the early part of the year 1895, at 21 Grant St., in Baltimore City, and had there begun operations as a manufacturer’s agent of wooden ware and kindred merchandise. That Harry W. Smith, the defendant, had been taken into the employ of the old firm .of Lord and Robinson when he was a boy fifteen years of age, and had continued in its employ for many years until the failure of that firm in 1893.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.