Supreme Court of North Carolina May 20, 1908 (Bruce v. Carolina Queen Consolidated Mining Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-05-1908

Bbown,

J.,

after stating the facts: 1. The evidence supports the finding that this defendant was placed in possession and charge of the land belonging to the defendant mining company as a caretaker by the officers of the corporation. As the action is brought against him by the trustee of the mortgage bondholders of the mining corporation to' recover possession of the land, to which the corporation does not object and files no answer, it is elementary that the defendant Boyd can no more contest his title than he could that of the corporation itself, whose officers employed him and placed him in charge of its property.

The action is brought by Bruce, trustee of the bondholders under'a mortgage, which the corporation does not contest, for possession of the property and for an accounting from Boyd for alleged profits received by him from the property. Being a mere agent or caretaker, it does not lie in his mouth to con

*644

test tbe validity of a mortgage admitted by tbe corporation wbo hired him. The referee and his Honor very properly sustained the demurrer to his amended answer.

2. The demand for a jury trial cannot be entertained. Not only does the said defendant ask for a reference in his answer of June Term, 1906, but when a reference was ordered at December Term, 1906, it was in express terms a reference by consent. The defendant’s counsel not only did not note any exception to the order of reference, but in unmistakable terms signified their consent in writing. It is now too late to demand a jury trial upon any issue.

Nissen v. Mining Co.,

104 N. C., 309;

Driller Co. v., Worth,

117 N. C., 518.

3. The only other question presented in the record which Ave deem necessary to consider is as to whether Boyd has any lien on the property for his services as caretaker.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.