Supreme Court of North Carolina April 1, 1908 (Whitfield v. . R. R.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-04-1908

CLARK, C.J., dissenting, arguendo. The court submitted these issues: 1. Was the plaintiff injured by the negligence of the defendant company? Answer: "Yes." 2. Did the plaintiff by his own negligence contribute to said injuries? Answer: "No." 3. What amount, if any, is the plaintiff entitled to recover of the defendant? Answer: "Five hundred dollars." At the conclusion of the evidence the defendant moved to nonsuit the plaintiff, which motion was denied, and defendant excepted. From the judgment rendered defendant appealed. The facts are stated in the opinion of the Court. The plaintiff was a brakeman of a freight train, in defendant's employment. At the time of the injury he was not on duty, but was on his way to his home at Mount Olive from Wilmington. He was traveling on a freight train by permission of the "boss man," who refused him a pass, but told him to get aboard the freight and go home. Plaintiff was riding on the engine when the train reached Magnolia. The conductor directed him to get off and see the agent and inquire if there was a package of flowers for him. The conductor told plaintiff to get the flowers and then catch the train. The plaintiff testifies further: "I got off and went to agent and told him what Captain Southerland told me. The agent said there was no package there for Captain Southerland. I went back to get on the train. When I went to get on the train it gave a sudden snatch and threw me right under it. My left leg was cut off a little above the knee and my right forefinger near the upper joint. Do not know how fast the train was running when I tried to get on. I guess it was running 10 or 15 miles per hour. I had not been in the employment of the railroad quite two months at that time." No other evidence was introduced, and the case rests (238) *Page 176 entirely upon plaintiff's own version of the facts, and upon these facts we are of opinion that the judge erred in not sustaining the motion to nonsuit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.