Supreme Court of North Carolina November 5, 1908 (Cuthbertson v. . Morgan)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-11-1908
CoNNOR, J.,
after stating the case: We have examined the-record and exceptions in regard to the conduct of the trial, including his Honor’s instructions to the jury, and find no prejudicial or reversible error. His Honor instructed the-jury, upon the issue directed to the alleged mistake in the
*76
contract, in accordance with the decisions of this Court. It must, we think, be conceded that the evidence, in this respect,'was not so “clear, cogent and convincing” as -would have been required by a Chancellor, under the procedure prevailing prior to the change in our system of administering equitable remedies. The weight of the evidence, conceding that £¿11 of the witnesses were speaking truly, was against the contention of the defendant in that respect. Having held, however, that -although the 'evidence must be “clear, cogent and convincing” to entitle a party to correct or reform a written instrument, the Court had no'right to withhold the case from the jury. ■ If there was more than a scintilla of evidence, we cannot hold, as a matter of law, that the evidence is not “clear, cogent and convincing,” that being for the jury.
Lehew v. Hewit,
130 N. C., 22. The protection which the law theoretically throws around the rights of parties who have reduced their ’contracts to writing, is made of but little practical value when the jury may set aside the written word upon testimony which a Chancellor would consider entirely insufficient. In this record it appears, without serious contradiction, that the parties voluntarily went to an intelligent,disinterested draftsman, stated their agreement, and after Having read it to them, expressed themselves as satisfied and executed it. Two of the parties and the draftsman testified to this and, upon the testimony of the other party, an addi-" tiónál provision is inserted in the contract.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit