Supreme Court of Oklahoma February 18, 1908, No. 642, Ind. T. (Williams v. First Nat. Bank of Pauls Valley)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1908

TuRNER, J.

(after stating the facts as above). Plaintiff’s amended complaint, after formally declaring on the note, says: “Plaintiff further alleges and charges the truth to be that the said note was executed by the said Jennie Lee Williams for the ’ benefit of her separate estate; that at the time of the execution of said note a contest was pending before the Commission to the Five Civilized Tribes, which said body, at the time, under the law, had authority to entertain and hear the same between the said Jennie Lee Williams, one of the makers of said note, and Susan E Mays, the payee therein, to determine which of the

*277

said parties had a right to take in allotment a certain tract of land adjacent to the town of Maysville, Tnd. T.; that said note was executed by the said Jennie Lee Williams, S. L. Williams, and' S. T. Williams in consideration of the abandoning of said contest by the said Susan E. Mays ,the payee therein; that after said note was executed the said Susan E. Mays did abandon her contest and permitted the said Jennie Lee Williams to take said land in allotment, which she did, and the land thereby became her separate property”; that the said note had been transferred to it by the said Susan E. Mays for a valuable consideration; and that it is now the legal and equitable holder of the same, etc., and pray judgment on the note.

On January 26, 1905, defendants demurred to said complaint, which was overruled by the court and exceptions noted, and the first assignment of error which we, shall consider is:

“(1) The court erred in overruling and denying the general and. special demurrers of the defendants to the plaintiff’s first amended complaint, for the reason stated in said demurrers; the said amended complaint upon its face having shown that the plaintiff .seeks judgment against the defendants upon an illegal and void contract.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.