Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas December 2, 1908, No. 4046. (Duty v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-12-1908
DAVIDSON, Presiding Judge.
Appellant was convicted of perjury, his punishment being assessed at seven years in the penitentiary.
The indictment contains several averments setting up or alleging the crime of perjury. Motion was made to quash, and in part sustained and in part overruled by the court. Without copying the averments upon which perjury was predicated, it is sufficient to state in a general way that it was alleged that appellant was passing a certain point at a certain hour of the night and saw Phelan standing in the door of a saloon; that Phelan turned back and used some rather insulting remarks and a shot was fired by which Phelan
*614
was killed, and that appellant was standing in front or just passing the door when these things occurred. All the averments in the indictment were quashed except that which alleged perjury upon a statement that he was passing the door or was about in front of the door of the house in which the killing occurred.
Without going' into a discussion as to whether or not the false statement, if it was false, that appellant was passing along the sidewalk in front of the saloon where Phelan was killed was 'material, we have the question presented, under the motion to quash, whether or not a material portion of one count in an indictment can be quashed; leaving the remainder of the allegation intact. Under the authorities, we answer this in the negative. In Wade v. State, 52 Texas Crim. Rep., 619, an analogous if not practically the same question was presented.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit