Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York March 15, 1908 (Purcell v. Union Railway Co.)

MacLean, J.

Upon the evidence alone, one passenger supporting the testimony of the plaintiff and the conductor, and another passenger, a woman, that of the motorman, the jury might have resolved the questions of fact either way and found a verdict not here to he disturbed, notwithstanding some inconsistencies on the plaintiff’s part respecting points of the compass and the direction in which he