Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 6, 1908 (People v. Cornell)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1908
Spring, J.:
The appellant was the editor and proprietor of the Fulton Patriot a newspaper published in the city of Fulton, Oswego county, in January, 1906, and for some time preceding. Early in 1906 it was currently reported that Merrick Stowell, county judge and a prominent citizen of said county, was an applicant for the important position of State Commissioner of Excise, which was soon to be filled by the Governor of the State. Judge Stowell had long been active in the management of Republican politics in the county and quite naturally had engendered considerable bitter opposition among partisans disagreeing with him. A political organization of the county bearing the name *521of the Roosevelt Republican League comprised members opposed to Judge Stowell, and they held a meeting in the city of Oswego, January 12, 1906, at which the candidacy of Judge Stowell was discussed and resolutions adopted, animadverting severely upon his political activity, and especially while holding the office of county judge, and protesting against his selection for the State office mentioned.
The defendant was present at this meeting, participated in the discussions which were had, and at the request of some of the members published the resolutions in his newspaper, and the papers containing them were generally circulated among the citizens of the county, and he has been indicted and convicted of libel for their publication.
We do not intend to discuss the facts or questions involved, except only so far as deemed essential to enable us to pass upon certain rulings of the court, which, we believe, call for a reversal of the judgment.
The article published is lengthy and is set out in full in the indictment. The part which is now pertinent reads as follows: “ He (Judge Stowell) has been County Judge of our county for thirteen years, and during that time, he has shown a pitiful and most miserable lack of conception of the dignity and nobility of judicial position.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit