Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court October 21, 1908 (Smith v. Scottish Union & National Insurance)

Sheldon, J.

1. In the first two of these cases the only question raised is whether the judge erred in refusing to rule, as requested by the defendant, that no statement in writing, signed and sworn to by the insured, was rendered to the company forthwith after the loss, as required by the terms of the policy; and that for this reason the plaintiff could not recover.