District Court, D. Puerto Rico July 31, 1908, No. 553 (Besosa v. Candina)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-07-1908

Rodey, Judge,

delivered tire following opinion:

The issue before us is raised by the demurrer of the defendant to the complaint. The suit is for alleged violation of a contract, and damages are claimed in the sum of $15,000. The matter was fully argued by counsel for the respective parties, and thereafter they each filed before us somewhat extensive written arguments. Neither counsel has cited us to any authority or adjudged ease in point, each appearing to proceed upon the idea that the matter is so simple that the court ought to be able to decide it on general principles.

It is a most peculiar case. Shortening the allegations of fact in the complaint, they are about as follows:

That the plaintiff and defendant had been, for a couple of years previous to June, 1901, engaged as partners in the business of buying, selling, and manufacturing drawn work, embroideries, fancy needle work, and other linen products,' under the firm name of the Porto Rico Drawn Work & Embroidery Company. That their main object was to increase and extend said business, so as to introduce their goods on a large scale into *250the United States. That the business had been growing continually, but its income had been put back into the business, and that it had become valuable and capable of still greater development. That about the month of June, 1907, the parties agreed that a corporation should be formed, and that they would transfer their partnership business to it, and take its stock in payment therefor. That under this plan, as agreed to between the parties, the defendant agreed to secure an increase in the capital to be invested in the. business by the sale of stock in the corporation to his friends and others, and thus enable said corporation to carry out its original object of introducing its products and business into the United States.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.