Supreme Court of Iowa July 9, 1908 (Nolan v. Reed)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1908
Ladd, C. J.—
The defendants, as members of the board of supervisors of Iowa county, are alleged to have been guilty of such lapses in the discharge of their official duties as to render them responsible for the death of plaintiff’s decedent, who in passing along the highway in going toward Belle Plaine, without fault on his part, drove his team from the traveled way into a ditch, and was killed. The particular acts of negligence alleged are in omitting to erect barriers along the embankment; in not maintaining signal lights or otherwise warning the public of the danger of the ditch; in *70permitting the highway to become and remain unsafe because of the proximity of the ditch to the traveled way; and in maintaining the highway but forty feet wide, when it might have been done at sixty-six feet in width. According to the petition, the board had ample funds and had undertaken to improve and repair the road by the expenditure of $250. But it was not averred that anything done by the board was performed improperly, or that its expenditures on the highway had rendered it less safe to travelers or interfered with the care and maintenance of the road by the township officers. In other words, the sole complaint is that these officers have been guilty of non-feasance, in that they as members of the board did not see to it that a road in dangerous condition was made safe. That duty is not imposed on the board of supervisors, but on township officers. Chapter 2, title 8, Code; Taylor v. Davis Co., 40 Iowa, 295; Wilson v. Wapello Co., 129 Iowa, 77. Section 1482 of the Code does not conflict with this view; for, while it gives the board supervision of the roads of the county, it defines wherein by adding, “ with power to establish, vacate, and change them as herein provided and to see that the laws in relation to them are carried into effect.” Negligence in either of these respects is not alleged.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit