Supreme Court of Iowa September 25, 1908 (Keniston v. Todd)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-09-1908
Weaver, J.— I.
i. Sales: breach of warranty. Appellant questions the sufficiency of the evidence to sustain a finding for the defendant; but the point is not well taken. The testimony on part of appellee fairly tends to show a warranty that the machine was in good condition and capable of doing good work. It also tends to show a breach of the warranty, and that the machine was of comparatively small value. There was no error, therefore, in submitting the case to the jury.
*2898. breach or waNer” par-mentfy *288II. The appellee having conceded on the trial that he *289made certain partial payments on the notes after he discovered the defective condition of the machine, counsel argue that this conduct operates as a waiver of the right to plead the breach of warranty as a basis of a counterclaim for damages. No authority is cited holding to this doctrine. Payment of the purchase price, especially full payment, after knowledge of the breach of warranty, may raise a presumption or inference, though not conclusive,, against the validity of the demand for damages; but, in the absence of some other controlling circumstances the mere fact that the purchaser has made partial payment of the price has never been held to waive his right to a counterclaim for damages for breach of warranty in an action against him by the seller for the unpaid remainder of such price. Certainly the waiver or pm sumption of settlement, if one exists, does not eliminate his right to set off his damages to the extent at least of the balance due on the contract price. Gilmore v. Williams, 162 Mass. 351 (38 N. E. 976) ; Osborne v. Marks, 33 Minn. 56 (22 N. W. 1) ; Nauman v. Ullman, 102 Wis. 92 (78 N. W. 159) ; McClure v. Williams, 65 Ill. 390. The case of Berthold v. Seevers Mfg. Co., 89 Iowa, 506, cited by counsel, does no more than announce the familiar rule that where property is delivered to the.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit