Court of Appeals of Kentucky September 29, 1908 (Guilfoyle's Exr. v. City of Maysville)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-09-1908
Opinion of the Court by
Chief Justice O’Rear—
Sustaining motion.
The city of Maysville proposing to improve certain of its streets at the exclusive cost of the abutting lot owners under the provision of the act of March 24, 1908, passed an ordinance requiring the construction of cement sidewalks along Bridge street and abutting plaintiff’s property. Many years ago a pavement of brick, with stone curbing, had been built along and in front of plaintiff’s property, which it is alleged is yet “in a fairly serviceable condition.” The act of 1908 allows the city to order the original construction of such- improvements at the exclusive cost of the abutting owners, and to issue 10-year bonds against the property which does not pay in cash, as its owner may do. The ordinance appears to have been regularly adopted in this instance, so as to bring the provisions of the statute into play, if the statute is con*534stitutional, and if the work is original construction within the meaning of the statute. Plaintiff filed this suit to obtain an injunction against the city, restraining it and its contractors from undertaking the work under this statute, mainly on the ground that the work was not original construction. The injunction was granted by the circuit judge. This is a motion before the undersigned judge of the court of appeals to dissolve the injunction. I have taken the matter before all the judges in consultation, except Judge Barker, who was absent. The following is the conclusion at which we arrived: Until ■ property once bears specifically the cost of building a pavement abutting it, done upon the order of the city council, or done by its express permission, indicated by order or resolution of its legislative body, there has not been an original construction of such improvement. The time .when and the manner in which the city’s highways shall be improved are matters peculiarly and exclusively within the discretion of the city’s legislative department.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit