Michigan Supreme Court January 31, 1908, Docket No. 110 (Bartlett v. Jenkins)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-01-1908
Hooker, J.
The parties to this action are farmers and neighbors. During the absence from home of the defendant the plaintiff went to his farm and obtained from the tenant eight bushels of wheat for seed. The plaintiff testified on the trial that he had previously spoken to the defendant about the possibility of his wanting some wheat, and that defendant consented to his having it; that he did not intend to steal it; never denied getting it; expected and promised to pay for it. The defendant denied that he had previous talk with the plaintiff about the wheat, and testified that the first he knew about the matter was when he was informed by his tenant and another person, both of whom were present and aided in getting the wheat for plaintiff after plaintiff had obtained the key to the granary from defendant’s wife, to whom he returned it afterwards. There was testimony that tended to show some ill feeling between the parties over a debt owing by plaintiff’s step-father, at the time of his death, which plaintiff, who cared for him during his illness and to whom deceased’s property was bequeathed, promised to pay, but did not pay promptly, which led defendant to institute probate proceedings. This ill feeling, if any existed, was not very clearly proved, but was an element in the cause which was for the jury to consider.
A short time after plaintiff obtained the wheat, defendant made a complaint for larceny and caused plaintiff’s arrest. The complaint was made under alleged advice of counsel and the magistrate after a statement which defendant claims included all the facts in his possession, and after counsel had talked with the prosecuting attorney. After one or more adjournments of the case the plaintiff was discharged by the justice after a jury had been summoned to try him, and before they were sworn.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit