Michigan Supreme Court May 1, 1908, Docket No. 52 (Dice v. Sherberneau)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-05-1908
Grant, C. J.
( after stating the facts). Five errors are alleged:
(1) The court misinterpreted the statute above quoted.-
(2) In submitting to the jury the question whether the defendant Sherberneau is liable for the sale of the liquor by Curtis to Dice.
(3) The verdict is excessive.
(4) It is against the weight of the evidence.
(5) The court erred in refusing to grant a new trial.
1. The court instructed the jury that if Dice shot and killed himself while in an intoxicated condition, and that defendant Sherberneau was responsible for selling intoxicating liquor to him, which contributed to his intoxication, the defendant was liable. ■
Counsel for the defendants contend that it was incumbent upon the plaintiff to prove that the intoxication was the cause of her husband’s suicide, and that the mere fact of committing the deed while in a state of intoxication is not sufficient to sustain a verdict. Counsel seek to make a distinction between an act committed by an intoxicated person towards others in consequence of which injury results to his family or the death from exposure or drowning, or being killed in a drunken brawl while intoxicated, and the act of suicide while the person is intoxicated. No case involving suicide by an intoxicated person has before been presented to this court. In an early case under this statute, this court said:
“The statute provides as plain as the English language can state it, that this action shall lie for any injury occas*604ioned by an intoxicated person. It is not for the injured party to produce proof, or for the jury to speculate, upon the probabilities whether the intoxication was the natural cause of the act which caused the death. The act itself by a person intoxicated fixes the liability for the damage upon the person selling or furnishing the liquor which caused the intoxication.” Brockway v. Patterson, 72 Mich. 122, 128 (1 L. R. A. 708).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit