Supreme Court of Minnesota December 11, 1908, Nos. 15,906—(123) (Somers v. Sturre)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-1908

START, C. J.

Appeal from an order of the district court of the county of Stearns, denying the plaintiff’s motion for judgment notwithstanding the ver*222diet or for a new trial. The sole question presented' by the record is whether the plaintiff is entitled to judgment notwithstanding the verdict.

The action was brought upon a check made and delivered by the defendant to the plaintiff, whereby the Stearns County Bank was requested to pay to the order of the plaintiff the sum of $2,750. The defense was, in effect, that the check was made and delivered to the plaintiff upon consideration that a certain stock of merchandise, then in the possession of the plaintiff in a building in the city of St. Paul, should be delivered to the defendant; but the plaintiff, upon getting possession of the check, refused to give up the possession of the stock. Thereupon the defendant demanded from the plaintiff the return of the check, which was refused. The defendant then refused to proceed further in the execution of the agreement for the purchase of the goods and stopped payment of the check. This defense was put in issue by the reply. At the close of all of the evidence the plaintiff requested the trial court to direct the jury to return a verdict for him. This was denied, and the court instructed the jury that the plaintiff was entitled to a verdict for the amount of the check unless the plaintiff refused to allow the defendant to take possession of and remove the stock of merchandise, that the burden of proof was upon the defendant to show such refusal, and, further, that this was the only question in the case. There was a verdict for the defendant. The evidence was sufficient to sustain the finding of the jury that the plaintiff did refuse, after receiving the check in payment therefor, to permit the defendant to take possession of the stock and remove it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.