District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania March 3, 1908, Nos. 44-46 (United States v. Marrin)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-03-1908
HOLLAND, District Judge.
In this case, in due time after verdict, the defendant filed motions in arrest of judgment and for a new trial. Neither of the six reasons set forth in arrest of judgment raises any question which the court can consider on this motion. Both questions variously stated, to wit, a failure of proof and a variance between the allegata and probata, are questions properly raised by a motion for a new trial. After verdict, a judgment will only be arrested for matter appearing on any part of the record which would render the judgment erroneous, if given. The rule in civil cases “that the matter alleged in arrest of judgment must be such as would upon demurrer have been sufficient to overturn the action or plea” is the same and applicable in criminal cases. Wharton’s Criminal Pleading & Practice (8th Ed.) *769§ 759; Sadler’s Criminal Procedure, § 51G. The indictment and record of the trial can alone be considered, and the evidence is no part of the record for the purposes of passing upon a motion in arrest of judgment. Commonwealth v. Gurley, 45 Pa. 392 ; Commonwealth v. Kammerdiner, 165 Pa. 222, 30 Atl. 929; Commonwealth v. Newcomer, 49 Pa. 478. Thus the motion will be sustained when it appears from the record that the court is without jurisdiction, or that the act of Assembly on which the indictment is framed is unconstitutional, or that the indictment is insufficient, but not when a support of the reasons depends upon a reference to the evidence adduced. Such objections can only be raised on a motion for a new trial, and as they are involved in the reasons set up in this motion, we will pass to the consideration of the motion and reasons for a new trial. They are 61 in number, but they will be considered as summarized by counsel for the defendant at the argument.
First.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit