Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit February 7, 1908, No. 1,386 (National Regulator Co. v. Powers Regulator Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-02-1908
BAKER, Circuit Judge
(after stating the facts as above). Reference patents prove that every element of the claims in suit was old. But in combining those elements Powers did something that was new and useful. The inquiry respects invention.
Without any aid from Powers a system of supplying heat and fresh air to school and other assembly rooms had been developed. Cold air from outside was conducted into the basement, and was forced along by a blower. One portion of the air passed over steam coils, and was highly heated. After the chill was taken from the remainder, the two currents in separate ducts were brought together in a trunk at the base of a single delivery pipe. A double damper was placed where the separate ducts united at the base of the single pipe. By means of a chain extending to the room to be heated by the single pipe the double damper could be manipulated. To the extent that one duct was closed the other was opened. This apparatus, minus the chain, is what is indicated in one of the two subcombinations of each of the claims in suit. Claim 1:
*462“In an air-heating and ventilating system, separate ducts for currents of air at different temperatures in combination with means for controlling the flow of the air currents.”
Claim 2:
“Separate ducts (as in claim 1) in combination with means for forcing the air, means for heating the current of air passing through one of the ducts and means for controlling the flow of the air currents.”
Claim 3:
‘■‘Separate ducts (as in claim 1) in combination with valves or dampers for controlling the ducts.”
The other subcombination of each claim relates to an apparatus that obviates the chain, and automatically moves the double damper in response to variations of temperature in the room. Claims 1 and 2:
“A gradually-acting thermostatically-governed motor.”
Claim 3:
“A pneumaticauy-operated pressure device operating against a gradually-increasing resistance, and a thermostat.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit