Court of Appeals for the First Circuit June 19, 1908, No. 759 (Eastern Dredging Co. v. Winnisimmet Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-06-1908
PUTNAM, Circuit Judge.
In this case a collision occurred in the inner harbor of Boston between a mud scow, about 110 feet long, and the ferryboat City of Boston, which was plying regularly between Chelsea and Boston. The collision was of such violence as to sink the ferryboat. It occurred about 10 o’clock in the evening. The weather was clear and starlight, and yet it was dark on the water. There was said to be just wind enough to ruffle the surface of the *861harbor, and this prevented the reflection of the lights on the shores, and, of course, somewhat darkened it. The scow was adrift, without any one aboard of her, which, of course, threw on her the burden of showing why she was adrift, and made out a prima facie case of negligence. It appears she had been left with her lines run out to the wharf, with no one aboard. There were no lights; but, as she was moored to the wharf, this did not charge her with fault. Some one in the neighborhood was employed to watch her, but was ignorant of her going adrift until about 9 o’clock in the evening. We have no occasion to trouble ourselves with reference to the negligence of the watch, either in not properly observing the scow or in not pursuing her, because, as the night was not a boisterous night, and, as we have said, with only sufficient wind to ruffle the water, the scow* would not have been adrift if she had been properly moored. This was sufficient to charge her owners with negligence; and the District Court found her guilty, as to which the learned judge of that court was undoubtedly correct.
On the other hand, the District Court relieved the ferryboat from any liability. The facts as to her were that she had no lookout forward, although, of course, the main deck of an ordinary ferryboat affords an excellent opportunity for a lookout well forward and so near to the water that his eye can easily follow its surface. The only lookout was in the pilothouse, about 50 feet aft of the bow and some. 20 feet above the water.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit