Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit June 3, 1908, No. 261 (Consolidated Rubber Tire Co. v. Diamond Rubber Co. of New York)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-06-1908

lead-opinion

COXE, Circuit Judge.

This appeal is in the nature of a reargument of the questions decided in the Firestone Case. It is not here upon newly discovered evidence, for the additional testimony was as available in that case as in this. There is more testimony it is true but it is cumulative merely. • The counsel are the same, the issues are the same. The judge of the Circuit Court correctly states the situation as follows:

“The question in this case was presented and tried out before Judge Platt and before the Circuit Court of Appeals; evidence was taken and experts examined. One side gave evidence that the wires would hold the tire firm and immovable, and the other side gave evidence that they would not. Now, in this case, you have called more experts giving the same kind of evidence, that the wires would not allow the tires to tip, but in my opinion that evidence is merely cumulative, and could not, in the nature of the ease, present *893any such different result that this court would be justified in not following the opinion of the Circuit Court of Appeals. Of course, if your defense was that this defendant does not infringe, that would be an entirely different question, but the only question argued here is as to the validity or invalidity of the patent.

“That question having been once tried out and a decision made, I do not see what right any other defendant had to go over the same evidence and call upon the court to go over it again, particadarly when the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals is controlling. In my opinion the only point in this ease, that of the validity of the patent, has been decided by the Circuit Court of Appeals.”

We think the judge was justified in so bolding. If courts are to examine defenses in patent cases de novo, as often as they are presented, litigation will continue until the resources of the defendants or the patience of the complainant, and possibly the patience of the court, are exhausted.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.