U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern New York June 27, 1908 (Clarke v. Atlantic Stevedoring Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1908

CHATFIELD, District Judge.

The plaintiff in this action is the assignee of 96 colored longshoremen, who went to work at the suggestion and apparently under the direction of the plaintiff, who had received a letter from one Charles M. Tiffany, superintendent of the defendant, which is as follows:

“New York, May 3rd, 1907.

“Mr. William Clarke, New York City — Dear Sir: I have work immediately for 200 colored longshoremen, and can guarantee the above number continuous *424work, providing they are good men. This Company pays the usual rate of wages, namely, 30$ per hr. for day and 45$ per hr. at night. We propose to keep colored men at work as long as they fulfill their part of the program. Attached letter-head will show you the work we do.

“Yours truly, Chas. M. Tiffany, Supt.”

The plaintiff and his 96 assignors went to work for the defendant, and were employed and paid up to the 6th day of July, 1907, when they were discharged and their places filled by white longshoremen. The plaintiff on his behalf, and because of the transactions with each of his assignors, has claimed $1,000 damages each for breach of what he alleges was a contract to furnish continuous employment at a reasonable rate of wages. The complaint alleges that the defendant has failed to give employment to each of the plaintiff’s assignors from the time of the breach until the present date.

The defendant has demurred, and claims (1) that the letter was not an offer by the acceptance of which the defendant would be bound to employ any particular person; (2) that, if a contract existed, its duration was indefinite, and in fact amounted to but an employment at will; (3) that the inducement was offered by the superintendent of the defendant, and that the defendant was an undisclosed principal; (4) that the advertisement called for 200 men and that but 96 appear to have gone to work, thus showing a lack of compliance on the part of the libelant. It is unnecessary to discuss these last two grounds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.