Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit December 15, 1908, No. 79 (Burton v. Berthold)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1908
NOYES, Circuit Judge.
In this action the defendants in error, who were the plaintiffs below and are hereinafter so designated, sought to recover from the plaintiff in error, hereinafter called the defendant, the price of certain lumber sold and delivered, or attempted to be *417delivered. The plaintiffs are wholesale lumber dealers located in St. Louis, Mo., and the defendant is a wholesale lumber dealer located in New York City. On April 6, 1904, the defendant received from E. W. McClave & Son of Newark, N. J., an order for 200,000 feet of long leaf yellow pine lumber, “sound and square.” The defendant contracted with the plaintiffs to fill this order at a lower price; the difference constituting his profit. This contract is evidenced by a written order and a letter of acceptance. On April 14, 1904, the defendant sent the order, specifying the amount required, the price, sizes, place of delivery, and other particulars, designating the lumber as “sound, square edge, rough, long leaf yellow pine” and concluding with these words: “Ship no waney stock” — i. e., timber not square-edg'ed. On April 19, 1904, the plaintiffs wrote the defendant unconditionally accepting the order, but inquiring whether his customer would be willing to have the lumber dressed, instead of in the rough, as specified in the order. This modification, however, was not agreed to.
The plaintiffs passed the order on to be filled by certain millmen in practically the same form, except presumably as regards price, as it was received from the defendant. On May 10, 1904, plaintiffs wrote the defendant that they were receiving complaints from the mills relative to the specification of the contract regarding wane, but saying:
“We have given the mills the exact specifications which we have received from you.”
The plaintiffs further suggested that the defendant inform his customer of the difficulty in securing sticks of the required size absolutely free from wane.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit