U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern New York April 3, 1908 (Page Mach. Co. v. Dow)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-04-1908
lead-opinion
HAZEL, District Judge.
This action is brought to enjoin infringement by the defendant of letters patent No. 558,506, dated April 81, 1896, issued to Benjamin E. Merritt and John M. Joy, for printing-telegraph, No. 780,664, dated January ,84, 1905, to John M. Joy, for printing-telegraph receiver, and No. 786,294, dated April 4, 1905, to John M. Joy, for clutch mechanism. These improvement patents are embodied in printing-telegraph machines known as page-tickers, which *474are chiefty used in broker’s offices and banks, and electrically record on sheets of paper news items relating to stock operations, fluctuations of the market, etc. The main defenses are that the patents are anticipated, and want of patentable novelty.
The invention for clutch mechanism, which will be first discussed, is not limited to any special form or class of machinery. Several modified structures of equivalent arrangements are shown in the drawings, but it is enough to consider fig. 3, which is the particular form of device alleged to be infringed by the defendant. Complainant emphasizes that part of the specification which declares the object of the patentee to be—
“to improve upon such forms of driving-clutches and prevent more than the desired stress being placed upon the spring or springs in the operation of the clutch.”
I think the improvement discloses patentable invention. A clutch mechanism for connecting and disconnecting parts of a mechanism or winding up a spring while other parts are assembled or juxtaposed is very old. It was also old to use and wind up a spring between a constantly rotating driving shaft and intermittently revolving type-wheel, and, moreover, the use of a friction clutch to prevent overwinding was common. The improvement in suit, however, is designed to secure a uniform strain on the spiral spring, and thereby absolutely prevent the breaking or overwinding of the spring.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit