Supreme Court of the United States April 6, 1908, 155 (McCabe & Steen Construction Co. v. Wilson)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-04-1908

Mr. Justice Brewer,

after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court.

When the plaintiff rested the court overruled a demurrer to the evidence. This ruling, however, cannot avail the defendant, whatever the defects then in the case, for thereafter it proceeded to introduce testimony in its own behalf, and this waived any supposed error.

Accident Insurance Company

v.

Crandal,

120 U. S. 529, 530;

Robertson

v.

Perkins,

129 U. S. 233, 236;

Bogk

v. Gassert, 149 U. S. 17, 23;

Campbell

v.

Haverhill,

155 U. S. 610.

The petition averred that one Pratt was defendant’s superintendent of construction and one Fallahey foreman of the gang engaged in work on the bridge, and that the plaintiff was employed by the defendant through its general superintendent. The answer, in addition to certain special defenses, was

*277

an unverified general denial, and the court held that under the pleadings the defendant was estopped from showing that the foreman of the bridge gang and the superintendent of construction were not in its employ. This ruling was based upon par. .3986 of the Oklahoma General Statutes of 1893, c. 66, § 108, which provides that “in all actions allegations . . . of any appointment or authority . . . shall be taken as true unless the denial of the same be verified by the affidavit of the party, his agent or attorney.” Defendant also sought to prove that plaintiff was not in its employ; that it in fact did not exist at the time of the accident; that the contract for the construction work was taken by a partnership, McCabe & Steen. The answer of defendant alleged that the injury to plaintiff “ was due to one of the risks assumed by the plaintiff in his contract of employment with this defendant.”

. The general denial in the answer as originally filed was in terms of “ the allegations contained in the petition in manner and form as therein set forth.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.