Supreme Court of North Carolina March 10, 1909 (State v. . Cale)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1909

Hoke, J.,

after stating tbe case: According to the strict rules of criminal procedure, tbe pleas of “not guilty” and “former conviction” could not be entertained and determined before one and tbe same jury; and it is further recognized and established that, on a plea of former conviction, when material questions of fact are involved in tbe issue, as in tbe case of dispute as to tbe identity of tbe parties, tbe determination of such plea is for tbe jury. But, as shown in a learned opinion by tbe present Chief Justice, in

State v. Ellsworth,

131 N. C., 773, tbe plea of former conviction is not treated in many respects as one involving tbe substantial question of guilt or innocence of defendant, but as one approaching more nearly tbe determination of a civil issue, and by consent it may be entertained and determined at tbe same time witb a plea of not guilty, and, when so agreed upon, may be beard and decided by tbe court. There was no error, therefore, in tbe method by which, tbe cause has been determined.

State v. Taylor,

133 N. C., 755;

State v. White,

146 N. C., 608;

State v. Ellsworth,

131 N. C., 773;

State v. Akerman,

64 N. J. L., 99.

While we bold that tbe proceedings below have been in all respects regular, we do not take tbe same view of tbe facts

*808

relevant to defendant’s plea of former conviction which seems to have impressed the learned judge who tried the cause below. From the facts it appears that defendant, convicted and fined in the present proceedings for a simple assault on Grover Harrell, has heretofore been convicted and fined for the same offense before a justice of the peace, and has paid the fine and the costs incident to that prosecution. The justice’s court had jurisdic-[ tion of the crime, the parties 'and the offense are the same, and, unless the proceedings before the justice were a nullity, the defendant has a constitutional right to go quit of further molestation by reason of this charge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.