Supreme Court of North Carolina April 7, 1909 (Hockfield v. Southern Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-04-1909
Clark, C. J.
The plaintiff introduced two of the four paragraphs of the answer filed before the justice of the peace. The defendant offered the other two paragraphs. In
Lewis v. Railroad,
132 N. C., 382, it is said: “Where a paragraph of an answer admits a specific fact, and in another part of the same paragraph denies the allegations of the corresponding paragraph of the complaint, the plaintiff is entitled to introduce the admission without introducing the part denying the allegations of the complaint.” Here the paragraphs of the answer put in evidence by the plaintiff were' complete in themselves, and it' was not error to exclude the distinct averments in its own interest made by the defendant. It could put on evidence in support of them at the trial.
Stewart v. Railroad,
136 N. C., 385.
A transfer company was in the habit of hauling goods for plaintiff and others, but that only made it the agent of plaintiff as to goods actually hauled. There was no evidence that the transfer company was told to haul these goods, and it was not error to exclude a question asked of an agent of such transfer company to show notice given to him of plaintiff’s goods being in the depot, when there was no evidence that such notice, if given, was communicated to the plaintiff. The plaintiff testified that he applied for the goods in person repeatedly.
The court allowed the plaintiff to amend its complaint and the defendant to amend its answer, but not to plead the statute of limitations. The amendment did not set up a cause of action wholly different, but merely amended the complaint to claim the penalty of $50 under the Revisal, sec. 2633. Such amendment was in the discretion of the court; as was also the refusal of an amendment pleading the statute of limitations.
Parker v. Harden,
122 N. C., 111;
Godwin v. Fertilizer Co.,
123 N. C., 162.
The fourth exception is abandoned. The fifth exception presents the contention that this is an interstate shipment, and that the Revisal, sec.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit