Supreme Court of Oklahoma September 14, 1909, 2115 (Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Coyle)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-1909

Turnee, J.

This is a proceeding in error from an action brought by John Arthur Coyle, defendant in error, plaintiff below, in the probate court of Greer county against the Western Union Telegraph Company, plaintiff in error, defendant below, to recover $200 actual damages and $50 penalty, under Wilson’s Rev. & Ann. St. 1903, § 729, which is as follows:

“Every person whose message is refused or postponed, contrary to the provisions of this chapter, is entitled to recover from the carrier his actual damages, and fifty dollars in addition thereto.”

The petition substantially states that on December 23, 1905, plaintiff by J. B. Lenertz, his authorized agent, delivered to defendant for transmission a message which read as follows:

“Granite, Oklahoma, Dec. 23, 1905. To George Austin, care of Austin Drilling Co. Paola, Kans. Will accept offer of Shay, F. O. B. Granite. Ship at once. This is a new line. Am on deal. Wire answer. J. B. Lenertz.”

That defendant accepted said message and agreed to transmit it and deliver it without unnecessary delay; that defendant failed to transmit said message. That the same accepted a proposition which had been made by said Austin to purchase a well-drilling cable. That by reason of the failure to transmit said message plaintiff was actually damaged in the sum of $200, for which he prayed judgment, together with the statutory penalty of $50, for postponing the message'. After answer, in effect a general denial, the cause was tried to the court, and judgment rendered in favor of plaintiff for $131.25, actual damages, and $50, the statutory penalty. As error defendant contends that the judgment is not supported by sufficient evidence, and is contrary to law, in that (1) there was no competent evidence introduced as to the actual damage sustained; and (2) that plaintiff, not being the sender of the message, cannot recover the statutory penalty.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.