Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas February 24, 1909, No. 4605. (Conley v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-02-1909
DAVIDSON, Presiding Judge.
Appellant was convicted of burglary, his punishment being assessed at two years confinement in the penitentiary.
He reserved a bill of exceptions which recites that the court erred in admitting the evidence of T. A. Meddings and Will Boll in rebuttal, which was for the purpose of contradicting the evidence of defendant’s witnesses. The reasons urged are, that these witnesses were in a place where they could see and hear the proceedings and evidence of defendant’s witnesses when they testified; that the door of the witness’ room was wide open and Meddings had his head in the door; that the witness Boll passed through the court room several times unaccompanied by an officer during the examination of the defendant and his witnesses, although the rule had been invoked. The court approved the bill with this qualification : That the above witnesses stated they did not hear any of the testimony of defendant’s witnesses. The enforcement of the rule, if in fact it was invoked in this case, is- to some extent discretionary with the trial court and in order to require a reversal for its breach some injury must be shown. As this bill presents the matter, we are of opinion that no injury is shown or such as would require a reversal.
In the motion for new trial it is urged that the court should have given a charge in regard to' the age of defendant, to the effect that if the jury should find that at the time of the commission of the crime alleged, the defendant was under the age of sixteen, his punishment should be in the reformatory and not in the penitentiary. The mother of appellant testified at the time of the trial he was nearly seventeen years old; that his birthday was the 26th of March, and that he was sixteen years of age the March previous to the time she was testifying. The trial was had on the 18th of November, after appellant was sixteen on the 26th of the previous March.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit