Indiana Court of Appeals April 27, 1909, No. 6,229 (Shank v. Trustees of McCordsville Lodge No. 338)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1909

lead-opinion

Watson, C. J.

— Appellees brought this action against Lewis F. Shank as principal and George W. Heiny, William Booth and J. F. ITeinzman as his sureties on a bond and contract for the construction of a lodge building by appellant Shank as contractor.

The complaint alleges that “said Shank did not complete the building on the 1st day of June, 1903; that on said last-mentioned date said Shank failed and refused to take any further steps toward completing said building, and that this plaintiff was compelled to complete said building, and bear and pay, and did bear and pay, the expense of completing such building; that the said Shank failed to carry out his said contract in the following particulars, to wit.”

1. Appellants contend that the court erred in overruling the separate demurrers to the complaint, because it does not allege that appellees performed the terms and conditions of the contract on their part; but such an allegation is unnecessary, where it is shown that the defendant has repudiated the contract or refused to perform his part. Riley v. Walker (1893), 6 Ind. App. 622, 629.

2. 3. The assignments of error relate entirely to the pleadings, but it is unnecessary to pass on the sufficiency of the demurrers, as the special findings made and the exceptions to the conclusions of law thereon present the same question as do the demurrers, and the ultimate rights of the parties rest upon these findings and the conclusions of law thereon. Indiana Rolling Mill Co. v. Gas Supply, etc., Co. (1906), 37 Ind. App. 154; Chicago, etc., R. Co. v. Yawger (1900), 24 Ind. App. 460; Board, etc., v. Wolff (1906), 166 Ind. 325. In determining whether any error was committed in stating the conclusions of law on the special findings, we necessarily determine the sufficiency of the pleadings.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.