Michigan Supreme Court April 24, 1909, Docket No. 112 (Detroit Realty Co. v. Barnett)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-04-1909

Hooker, J.

(after stating the facts). Upon this record we must treat the case as one to be heard de novo. The complainants do not ask, and defendants have not saved their right to ask, that the case be remanded for further testimony, notwithstanding the fact that the court said during the discussion:

“ The Court: The question in this case is where a man is under license by the Government and by the State he stands upon another footing from one who erects a boiler shop or a machine shop or commits a nuisance that way; and the question here is: Can the Wayne circuit court restrain the commission of a crime ? Like the closing of a saloon or correcting saloons, the regulation of conduct or the disorderly conduct of the saloon business, can they do that in the Wayne circuit court? Where we are fenced off from the city of Detroit, and.where while we have the entire civil jurisdiction over the city, we have not the criminal jurisdiction over the city whatever. Now, the defendant Barnett keeps a saloon and a restaurant under the State and United States licenses. He is under the State control. He has paid for his keeping the saloon open, and by the statutes of the State which you made, making him pay that license, and his hours are limited and bis duties are clearly defined. He has exceeded the limits and complainants’ rights.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.